Friday 4 December 2009
+ Hit.. WTF and how to optimise it
Step 1: +hit put your hit gear back on. It was here that I hit my first big hurdle. I only had + 184 hit rating. thats right 7.01% WTF. how had this happened.
It wasn't actually that much of a disaster. but it was a wake up call to be more careful about wanting to stack spell power and haste like crazy. So reconciling this back I got
+7.01% Equipment
+3.00% Arcane Spells (Talent Arcane Subtley)
+3.00% All Spells (Talent Precision)
+1.00% Assume Draenei is in the party
+3.00% Assume Boomkin/Priest
17.01% Total
Ok. so somewhere along the line my build had made sense. It was with this that I realised it was the move into 25 man raiding that made my current equipment choices viable. In a 10 man its to much to expect +4.00% hit coming from other sources.
And after talking to some Boomkins most of them don't even take the talent to give the hit bonus. /QQ
So it looks like rebalancing for hit should solve some problems. But then I was thinking... Surely because my DPS is still good (just not great) its being propped up. But how... It was then I remembered reading an artical way back when I was new about about the effect of critical strike on hit.
Wowwiki likes to think that critical strikes and hit are independant. That is its rolls to hit, and if you hit roles to crit.
Therefore (using modelling methods for simplicity)
Max + Hit and + 0.00% Critical Strike = 100.00% DPS
Max + Hit and + 1.00% Critical Strike = 101.00% DPS
Max + Hit and +2.00% Critical Strike = 102.00% DPS
99% Hit and +0.00% Critical Strike = 99.00% DPS
99% Hit and +1.00% Critical Strike = 99.98% DPS
99% Hit and +2.00% Critical Strike = 100.96% DPS
Clearly this is not favourable. but it does show that is your running short on +hit, raw power often from better itemised items can, overall, adjust favourably.
Now lets worst case this for myself.
90% Hit and +30% Critical Strike = 114% DPS (I actually normally have around 60% raid buffed)
so my additional DPS from critical strike is over halved. becuase I let my hit rating slip too low.
My remendy is actually very simple, I used the equipment manager to make some suits
Suit 1: + 7.01% is now my OMG everything is here spec and
Suit 2: +8.01% the Boomkin/Priest but no Draenei suit
Suit 3: +10.01% was created for Draenei in the party
Suit 4: +11.01% Fail suit, in that is suppiles all the + hit it needs itself.
My final comment is why the extra 0.01%? simple. to account for rouding errors.
I will let you know how this works out, as while I think having the extra options is nice, what if the Boomkin dies? what is the itemisation cost of +1% hit? Is it better to be hit capped simply to stop it becoming an issue when arguable +1.00% Crit ~ +0.99% hit (the ratio decreases exponentially)
Tuesday 10 November 2009
RAWR!
That’s right. You heard me… Now get to 80 and download this badboy! I am not going to tell you how to use it. Read the manual, but I will cover the basics as I want to rant about is how it helps to show what your upgrades are.
- Get rawr
- Download yourself from the armoury
- Go through the list and add every piece of equipment you have (including PvP gear),even if its not gemmed that way
- Save it… having to enter this again blows
- Go to the buffs tab and put your standard group into it (MMO Champion)
- Don’t forget your self buffs… Rawr will assume you change your Molten to Mage Armour and back.
I have been trying to get my mind around this and it’s hard!
- Go to filters and turn of the area’s where you can’t get upgrades from. For myself I have turned off ToGC25. Although we are stuck on Anub in ToC25 and are still struggling through ToCG10 including these items stops me from being to narrow in my future planning. Plus, we will get it done, its just when so knowing what is good for me is good for the guild.
If you have been watching the recommended upgrades you should have noticed this list has changed a lot, especially when you added your raid buffs. Later go back and see how different buffs affect you.
- Now its time to optimise, the first thing to do is choose what your optimising. I have found as a mage optimising for DPS and Overall Rating are very similar but optimising for DPS is would be more appropriate. Last step here is change to maximum thoroughness.
Again if you’re still keen later, run them both and see what happens!
When it finishes load it up and then run it again. And again, because of the computations involved it’s a best estimate. When you have done this a few times, congratulations! This is your equipment optimised for DPS.
- The most expensive part happens now… Rawr likes to change enchantments and gems- sometimes to combinations that look rubbish. Definitely give it a logic check and say to yourself- with these changes do I need to change how I play? Can I play like this? Will it still be fun!
- There are now two ways to get your upgrades list, either read what is on the right in the comparisons tab, or go back to optimisation and run an upgrade list.
Rawr unfortunately doesn’t organise them into nice lists of these are available from Naxx10, these from Uld25 etc so you need to do some messing around in this stage to see where your upgrades can be found and evaluate how hard it will be for you to get them.
I am very unlucky with my main hand and still have The Turning Tide as a significant upgrade!
I didn’t really think much about rawr prior to 3.2, I was Arcane and had a good idea of what items would boost me, but when the two other mages (Frostfire & fire respectively) found the change much more difficult. Why because their equipment was all wrong! They spend the first month of so of patch 3.2 will good but unexciting DPS. They where /oom, had no burst, and now wanted my equipment!
BUT I also freely admit that change from T8.5 to T9.0 was hard*. The itemisation was all wrong and you have to change into them two at a time else you are over penalised because of the change in itemisation. I won a 232 Ony10 headpiece that was good so I did Hands & Shoulders as my first set and then Chest & Legs
And guess what? The Chest has the worst itemisation of all of them for Arcane, why because it’s swapping +crit from T8.5 to +hit.
Anyway, I digress… Back to the topic at hand, now you have a list of items that will improve your Arcane DPS. Most of the items will just require time either by farming (Abyssal Rune from ToC5 normal) or collecting badges as unfortunately getting a group that’s able to penetrate deep enough into Ulduar is hard. Remember that the best items are not necessarily the highest item (i.e. Talisman of Volatile Power looks good, but will age very quickly, while Abyssal Rune will likely last well into 3.3).
There are a couple of items that can be purchased though if you’re cashed up, Spellslingers Slippers, Bejewelled Wizards Bracers, and Merlin’s Robe are the first to come to mind. Currently I would estimate them at 3.5k, 4.5k, 8.5k respectively, but each realm is different and everyone has different professions.
I also want to mention something that I thought was very odd in the current tier of equipment and that is how powerful staves are for arcane mages. I have Enlightenment (245) as best in slot followed by Cold Convergence (245), however these are unlikely as they drop in ToGC10. In our current farmable content ToC10/25 the staves are still in the top 5 **, so until I win Barb of the Tarasque I will be annoying my raid leader (and everyone else) by rolling on these too.
I am wondering if staves are an exception to the rule when it comes to arcane mages… I will keep this in mind for next tier of items
* My guild is a core 10 man at heart so no T9.5 for us… but T9.25 is well on the cards… IF I can ever win a damn trophy! haha
** I don’t include PvP items in this list, however again because of the amount of haste on these items they are very much up there if you can get them.
Monday 9 November 2009
Personal Topic: 10 MAN PUGing and the 10man guild.
First I want to clarify my topic. Is it better to be in an exclusive 10man raiding guild or be in some other type of guild- social, 25man etc and PUG 10?
I say personal topic because these are my opinions… no empirical evidence, no math, just Trade spam and embracing the ‘casual’ idol that is now WoW. Lets start with looking at what I think are some advantages and disadvantages of both
This topic popped into my head last week, when I read in Trade:
LFM 3x Imba DPS, 3x Healers for ToGC10. Will check Armoury, /w ToC10 achievement
Not to be a complainer but the person yelling this would not have been invited to my ToC25, let alone ToCG10! Although I maybe a little elitist! Sorry, but I want to win on current content.
I must admit that was very stunned. Are pugs really beginning to do stuff my guild can’t complete yet? Or is it simply to down the first boss or two for chance at some extra lewt?
SO heres a list straight of the top of my head.
10 man guilds
Advantages
- Gear stays within the group, therefore group gets stronger
- Community
- Do Achievements
- Easy to reform and continue a run another night
- Happy to ‘carry’ lower equipped members to get them lewt = stronger team
Disadvantages
- Very dependant on Tanks & Healers- losing one and finding a replacement can be painful. Especially is they are well equipped
- Some inflexible about raiding times
- Some personalities dominate
- Loot distribution, smaller guilds need to favour tanks & healers else the raid fails... regardless of how it officially is distributed.
- Because of the need for ‘spares’ some people will miss out on raiding spots and will start to be left behind equipment wise as they have to hold off pugging it.
- Need for certain classes can majorly handicap some encounters (Blizzard has addressed this in some ways)
10 man PUG
Advantages
- Can get in to group when it suits
- Group could be as a pug into a larger guilds run!
- No messing around- straight through!
- Some effort has been made to make sure no fail members in party (I.e armoury checks)
- Likely to be some over equipped players coming for badges or a specific drop
- Meet other/new people
- Random equal chance to win loot
Disadvantages
- Sometimes not enough toon’s of the right calibre are available so its either a fail or wastes your time as it can’t get sorted
- A few wipes can destroy moral and end a raid before it even started
- Hard to reform if it needs to be over different multiple nights.
- Lewt Ninja’s!
- A few ‘fails’ manage to sneak into every raid…
I am sure every can think of few that I missed.
So what do I think? To be honest I think both are methods of reaching for different goals. I don’t think I could do a 10 man exclusive guild anymore, but I do think Blizzard has tried to keep things mixed up, especially with upgrading the emblem drops as new tier becomes available.
PUG
Naxx10
OS10
VoA10 <except when new content>
VoA25 <except when new content>
OS25
10 man guild
OS10 + 1/2/3 * <I have done +3 a few times now and as a guild is much easier>
EoE10 *
Uld10 *
ToC10
ToGC10
10 man guild + friends**
EoE25 *
Nax25 *
Uld25
OS25 +1/2/3 *
25 man
Everything else! This area is beyond the scope of this article.
* Could be pugged but without some instant success generally loses moral to fast. Even though we are no in the end game of 3.2, I have seen plenty of Naxx25 fall apart after only a quarter or two.
** Ideally in the + friends format, all tanks & most healers are provided by the guild with DPS being outsourced to friends/alliances etc.
Final Thoughts
I guess these leads to my last thought… I don’t think 10 man guilds are optimal, even in ‘causal’; bring the player not the class WoW. They are holding to much internal risk.
But maybe there are perfect for finishing one tier behind content?
I think guilds should be aiming to run two ten-man teams! Arguable this opens up more content and achievements (hard modes etc) to more players and with a larger pool of equipped players it opens the door way to 25 man content in some form.
Trail of the Crusader is a great example of this its very easy to get two groups running ToC10 and then a progress group on ToCG10. This also means that for ToC25 most of the spots are taken up by guild members who you know are equipped with a very respectable ilevel for the content. Regrettably they will not be running this format again.
I do feel that I am not finished on this topic… To Be Continued!
Friday 30 October 2009
Haste, Haste, Haste! How the frak is it calculated?
The Wrong Way: 6% + 10% = 16% so Arcane Blast goes from 2.50 to 2.10 (2.50 x
(1-16%))
The Right Way: I will show all the steps here for clarity and try put the numbers into words
New Cast Time = base cast time divided by the product of the benefit of all haste sources
NCT = 2.50 / ((1 + 6%) x (1 + 10%))
NCT = 2.50/ (106% x 110%)
NCT = 2.50 / 116.60%
NCT = 2.14 seconds
Some care needs to be taken with this for example Hyperspeed Accelerators are increasing your haste rating not adding another source of haste like (for example) Heroism, Icy Veins, and a Wraith of Air Totem would. Just for kicks- if you popped Icy Veins right now it would look something like this
NCT = 2.50 / ((1 + 6%) x (1 + 10%) x (1 + 20%)
NCT = 2.50 / (106% x 110% x 120%)
NCT = 2.50 / 139.92%
NCT = 1.79 seconds
It can get very complicated during a boss fight with all the various sources interacting together. Your cast times will go all over the place!
So Now We Know How it Works, Lets Look at Arcane Numbers!
Arcanist's will have access to at least three pools of haste, Haste Rating, Netherwind Presence and Icy Veins, So lets have a quick look some cast times with these at different levels of Haste Rating. For simplicity I will use Arcane Blast as it will be the most common spam and top it off with a graph.
Base Casting Time 2.50 seconds
Haste Rating 0 (+ 0%)
+ Haste = 2.50
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 2.36
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.97
Haste Rating 164 (+ 5%)
+ Haste = 2.38
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 2.25
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.87
Haste Rating 328 (+ 10%)
+ Haste = 2.27
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 2.14
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.79
Haste Rating 492 (+ 15%)
+ Haste = 2.17
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 2.05
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.71
Haste Rating 656 (+ 20%)
+ Haste = 2.08
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 1.97
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.64
Haste Rating 820 (+ 25%)
+ Haste = 2.00
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence = 1.89
+ Haste + Netherwind Presence + Icy Veins = 1.57
Blogger is still fighting with me a little... I am sure I will get the hange of it soon!
Sunday 25 October 2009
Cyclical Spell Power Coefficients
For my Argent Tournament quest grind I like to use the following cycle.
Frostfire Bolt + Arcane Blast + Arcane Barrage
Cycle coefficient is 85.71% + 71.43% + (71.43% x (1+15%+3%)) = 241.43% *
* Arcane Blast is buffing Arcane Barrage by +15% and +3% for the glyph and I have ignored the FFB DoT as the mob will be well dead before the DoT deals significant damage
Its not very meaningful like this so breaking it down into per second, I feel, gives a really good indication. So assuming no haste benefits that's
3.0 + 2.5 + 1.5 = 7.0 seconds **
** It my personal style to add the global cool down as the time cost of an instant spell. You have to still be aware that is natural cool down is still 3.0 seconds if you want to do two in succession
241.43% / 7.0 = 34.49% per second
(for the curious if you only had Netherwind Presence that would increase this by +2.07% to 36.56%)
So in this cycle for every +10 spell power you have its adding +3.4 damage per second for a total of + 24 per 10 spellpower.
The cycle's coefficient per second does not look very sexy. But now we can build other cycles and explore 'The best cycle for class X spec Y' in a different way. I think this king of analysis is interesting for arcane due to how the Arcane Barrage buff stack, especially now that it goes up to four times for a massive +72% damage.
To cut to the chase, I built a graph with three different spell cycles
1. Arcane Blast spam ending with Arcane Missiles cast on Missile Barrage proc
2. Arcane Blast spam ending with Arcane Missile, but no Arcane Barrage proc
3. Arcane Blast spam ending with Arcane Barrage
In terms of maximising your spell power it looks like getting your Missile Barrage off early is a clear winner, followed by ending on an Arcane Barrage if long term Arcane Blast spam is unsustainable. In fact it does appear that if you move beyond x10, Arcane Barrage will gain more benefit.
This does seam to be inconsistent with the currently accepted Arcane Blastx4 + Arcane Missile. Likely this is because Arcane Blast buff increase the base damage of a spell- this type of analysis completely ignores the effect of two spells have the same cast time and spell power coefficient but different base damage and talents haven't been included (like spell impact), trinket or set bonus procs, critical strike, raid buffs the list goes on.
So some work is definitely needed here.
As a final note, I think this also shows how bad Arcane DPS can be without
Missile Barrage or even Arcane Barrage, all that spell power means nothing
if you can't effectively tap into it.
Tuesday 20 October 2009
Lets Talk Tier
Tier Seven: Frostfire Garb
Two Set: +40% mana from mana gem and +225 spell power for 15 seconds
Four Set: +5% critical strike spell damage
The two set was amazing for Arcane saving it for your I WIN macro* was a huge damage boost and it topped up your mana. I was in a 10 man guild, so there was no valorous gear for me in a hurry- so Glyph of the Mana Gem was a must with this set bonus.
The four set was nice, but since we where trying to stack haste it was not so sexy. This definitely favoured Fire / Frostfire builds' and strangely enough it was named for them!
Tier Eight: Kirin Tor Garb
Two Set: Arcane Blast has a chance to grant +350 spell power for 15 seconds
Four Set: There is a chance that Missile Barrage will not be consumed
when used
Again the two set was good, but four was a bit lame as normally you had moved on to Arcane Barrage or even into your Arcane Blast cycle before it was even noticed, At the time thought the Arcane Blast Buff only stacked three times and the chance for Missile Barrage to proc was half so it might be a bit different now.
No a personal note I did enjoy the pants suit (I know people where upset…) as I could finally wear a tabard for a while and not look like a tool.
Tier Nine: Khadgar's Regalia
Two Set: +20% armour from Frost Armour, +10% mana regeneration from Mage Armour, +15% extra critical strike from Molten Armour
Four Set: +5% critical strike with Arcane Blast and Arcane Missile.
I really like both of these set bonuses. But I am not a fan of how you get them. Emblems, Trophies, Tokens…
By the time your moving into Tier Nine your mana pool should be high enough that the additional regeneration from Mage Armour is not needed, meaning its molten armour all the way for 70% of spirit is converted into critical strike rating.
Passively stack critical strike this way is a win-win for arcane due to the increase in mana regeneration. I am not going to go into Student of the Mind now- I think that is a personal choice as there is some sacrifice needed to get this if you want to go this way.
The four set is interesting, since the current arcane cycle is Arcane Blast x4 Arcane Missile or even more Arcane Blast if you want to wait for Missile Barrage to proc, so its really a +5% critical strike to your whole cycle so I for one will find it hard to want to break the four set.
Although I will collect all five pieces of the set I consider the chest to be the weakest with +hit it's very easy to be massively over hit capped from raid ToC10/25. Ironically I think Blizzard planned for this and its why Merlin's Robe is so damn awesome, but at 8x Crusader Orb's I don't think I will be getting one anytime soon (obviously it will depend on your realm and gold- on EU Emerald Dream they are currently 800 - 900 each.).
Also for those curious the Hood of Fiery Aftermath shares the same stats as T9.25 hood and has the same badge cost (75) only you need a trophy… so do what you can to get that trophy!
Tier Ten: Unknown
Two Set: Missile Barrage also grants you +12% haste for 5 seconds
Four Set: Your Mirror Images grant you +18% damage for 30 seconds
These are currently in the Player Testing Realm and as such subject to change.
These both look really interesting to me and I think T9 (2) + T10 (2) will be worth holding onto until T10 (4) becomes available.
Also with the changes to Scorch and Frozen Core I have a feeling that Frostfire will be the spec of choice for T10, but don't despair! Arcane still looks to be strong especially if the change to Enchant Weapon- Black Magic (to a +Haste proc) comes throught as this is looking stronger than then mighty spell power!
My only concern with this set is that Mirror Image is changing from a general threat reduction to a serious DPS boost. Personally in my rotation I like to drop MI as part of my I WIN macro, just in case it goes a little crazy, but this potentially could add more aggro then it drops!
Summary
Our friends at EJ's have done the hard work of evaluating the set bonuses, although I do recommend that you get your hands on Rawr as access to different equipment will change what is good for you. For Arcane the set bonuses look to be as follows
Set Bonus: + DPS increase.
T7 (2): +2%
T7 (4): +1%
T8 (2): +2.5%
T8 (4): +1%
T9 (2): +1.5%
T9 (4): +2.5%
T10 (2): +?
T10 (4): +?
Tuesday 13 October 2009
Arcane Tree
The arcane tree runs out of DPS improving talents very quickly so its better to get them from other tree. It is a shame that the utility talents aren't very useful. There are few points that can spend to customise the spec, but they will change the playstyle of the spec. So lets have a look starting with Fire since we have 3 points in it
Fire
Tier 1
3 pts Incineration: +6% Critical Strike chane on Arcane Blast.
Frost
The whole point of points in frost is to get Icy Veins.
Tier 1
3 pts Ice Floes: lowers cooldown on Icy Viens, Frost Nova and Ice Block
2 pts Frostbite: Just as you have to use the points and its more useful here. Provides some benifit to grinding as I find the best rotation for this is FFB, AB, ABar
Tier 2
3 pts Precision: +3% hit will all spells, -3% base spell mana cost.
2 pts Ice Shards: +66% damage on critical strike. For when AoE is needed or FFB is used
Tier 3
1 pt Icy Veins: Lowers cast speed by 20% and reduces pushback for 20 seconds (cooldown 3 minutes/2 minutes 24 seconds with 3 points in Ice Floes).
Arcane
You will find from the ones I put x pts that you will need to go back and choice some of these as you will need 5 points per tier to move onto bying the next level of Talents.
Tier 1
2 pts Arcane Sublety: Reduces threat from Arcane spells by 40%
3 pts Arcane Focus: +3% hit with Arcane spells, -3% base spell mana cost of Arcane spells
x pts Arcane Stability: This one is personal choice, but pushback from being attacked really blows and this is one way of dealing with it- most people take three points and enjoy the pally -35% pushback buff.
Tier 2
0 pts Arcane Fortitude: this is not a PvE talent
x pts Magic Absorbtion: This increases resistance and when a spelll is fully resisted gives back mana. a very nice general talent.
5 pts Arcane Concentration: 10% chance after a spell hits of going into a clear casting state and the mana cost of the next spell cast reduced to 0. Not as tasty as it used to be (AB is now +175% rather than 200%), but still considered core. Due to is placement on the tree I think it would be difficult to not buy this talent and use the points effectively. To make up for this it recieves a benifit from Arcane Potency (Tier 6) for an additional critical strike chance
Tier 3
x pts Magic Attunement: Increases range of Arcane spells (x3 yards). while it doesnt' increase DPS in WotLK it has meant that you can be out of the range of AoE that various bosses do meaning it enables you to continue DPSing uninterupted.
3 pts Spell Impact: +6% damage Arcane Blast. This is massive, in terms of pure casting your going to be casting AB 80% of the time or more.
x pts Student of the Mind: up to +10% spirit. not really desirable until T8/9 equipment when used in conjunction with Molten Armour for additional crit. With Arcane don't really desiring crit it can be a nice boost, but will come at a cost of sacrificing a DPS talent elsewhere. This is not currently considered an optimal talent.
1 pt Focus Magic: Gives a buff to another player for 30 minutes of +3% spell critical strike, however when they crit you get +3% critical strike for 10 seconds.
Tier 4
x pts Arcane Shielding: Lowers mana cost of Mana Shield and increases resistances on Mage Armor. IF your using Mage Armour... it can be great for some additional resistances and should be used in conjuction with Magic Absorbtion.
0 pts Improved Counterspell: although I have put 0 here it could be taken but most bosses are immune to counterspell.
3pts Arcane Meditation: +50% mana regeneration during combat.
3pts Torment the Weak: +12% damage to snared or slowed targets. All tanks apply this in one way or another so its a core talent.
Tier 5
0 pts Improved Blink: While sexy is just not a PvE talent
1 pt Presence of Mind: instantly cast a spell with a cast time less than 10 seconds. A great DPS boost and recieves a bonus critical strike modifier from Arcane Potency (Tier 6).
5 pts Arcane Mind: increases intellect by 15%, +mana, +crit. very sexy but limited.
Tier 6
0 pts Primatic Cloak: Again very sexy but isn't a PvE talent
3 pts Arcane Instability: +3% critical spell strike and +3% damage all spells
2 pts Arcane Potency: +30% on your the spell benifiting from either PoM or CC
Tier 7
3 pts Arcane Empowerment: Gold increased damage of your main nukes AB & AM
1 pt Arcane Power: For the next 15 seonds all spells cost +20% mana but does +20% more damage
0 pts Incanter's Absorption: Sexy, but too situational for real benifit. Arguable would work well in fights that do constant damage or use frost/fire ward, as the use of Mana shield would be to expensive.
Tier 8
2 pts Arcane Flows: Lowers cooldowns PoM, AP and Evocation. Gold!
5 pts Mind Mastery: turns 15% of intellect into spellpower.
Tier 8
0 pts Slow: Very sexy for soloing but not so for raiding.
5 pts Missile Barrage: This is it... the bees knees of Arcane this is a huge DPS boost.
Tier 9
3 pts Netherwind Presnce: +6% haste = +6% DPS
2 pts Spell Power: +50% (a for a total fo +100%) damage on a critical strike of all spells
Tier 10
1 pt Arcane Barrage: Arcane only instant spell. Not so sexy at the moment, but very useful and no doubt will be back into the rotation after 3.2.2